Automated bidding amplifies a tracking error, it does not absorb it
Smart Bidding will not correct a measurement mistake. It will act on it faster and with more of your money. Here is how to see what the system actually sees.
The most common lead generation problem is not too few leads. It is plenty of leads, half of them useless.
It almost always comes from the same place. The ad system sees exactly one thing: somebody submitted the form. It has no idea whether that became a quote, a contract or nothing. If you do not tell it, it optimises for what it can see, which is the number of forms.
And since it is good at what it is asked to do, it will bring you a lot of forms. From increasingly easy to reach people.
The usual reaction is to narrow the targeting. That helps, but it does not solve it, because the system is still guessing who the good buyer is. Until it gets feedback, it will keep guessing.
What is needed is a feedback loop: the business outcome travels back to where the bid is decided.
Give every lead an identifier. The form should record where it came from. That is what the hidden fields are for: campaign identifiers, click id, landing page. Without those the loop cannot close.
Give it a status. Three levels is enough to start: not qualified, qualified, won. This is often one column in a spreadsheet. It does not require a CRM.
Send the status back to the ad system. Make the qualified lead the primary conversion rather than the form submission, and pass the won deal with a value.
Then let it learn. This part takes patience. If you revert after a week because the lead count dropped, the system learned nothing.
The lead count will fall. That is not a failure, it is the point. What rises is the share of enquiries that reach a proposal, and with it the return on the time your sales effort costs.
If somebody reports to you on lead count, they are improving a number that does not pay an invoice.
More posts
Smart Bidding will not correct a measurement mistake. It will act on it faster and with more of your money. Here is how to see what the system actually sees.
Automation is good at volume and speed. It is bad at judgement. A simple split that decides what you should let go of.
If a competitor gives more for the same price, bidding will at best buy you the same result at a higher cost. How to see where your offer actually stands.